Environmental Setting: 1-10

Tangible Emotions: 1-10

Amount of Whump: 1-10

Amount of hurt/comfort: 1-10

Uniqueness: 1-10

Unexpected events: 1-10

It would be nice if we can give kudos to the story.

And if the star rating had multiple parts. I think that this would help writers get better feedback when readers don't want to write things out.

It would be great to have rating points for these and add them all together and divide them for a real rating:

Overall Enjoyment: 1-10

Grammar, spelling, and punctuation: 1-10

Formatting easy to read: 1-10

Length of chapter: 1-10

Writing style: 1-10

Can visualize easily: 1-10

Development of the plot: 1-10

Believable characters: 1-10

Fits the theme of archive: 1-10

Intensity: 1-10

Want to read more: 1-10